| 1831-1883 |
Fr. Frederick Rese |
| 1832 |
Fr. F.X. Haetcher |
| 1833-1840 |
Fr. F.X. Tchenhens |
| Summer 1835 |
Fr. Simon Saenderl |
| 1835-1838 |
Fr. Peter Czakert( Assistant, 1835-1838 ) |
| 1838-1839 |
Fr. Joseph Prost (Assiastant) |
| 1840 |
Fr. Matthias Wuerz |
| 1840 |
Fr. Henry Damien Junker |
| 1840 |
Fr. Basil Schorb |
| 1840 |
Fr. Joseph McNamee |
| 1840 |
|
| 1840-1841 |
Fr. Joseph Freigang |
| July – November 1841 |
St. John Nepomucene Neumann, C.SS.R.
First American Redemptorist Fourth Bishop of Philadelphia Declared Heroic in Virtue 1921 Declared Blessed in 1963 Declared Saint June 19, 1977 |
| 1841-1843 |
Fr. F.X. Tchenhens |
| November 1842-January 1844 |
Rev. L. Mathias Alig, C.SS.R. |
| Spring 1884 |
Fr. Bonaventure Faulhaber |
| 1844-1847 |
Very Rev. Francis Brunner, C.PP.S. |
| 1844-1847 |
Rev. John van der Broek, C.PP.S. | Rev. Mathias Kreusch, C.PP.S. | Rev. Peter Anton Capeder, C.PP.S | Rev. Maria Anton Meyer, C.PP.S. | Rev. Jacob Ringele, C.PP.S. |
Rev. John Wittmer, C.PP.S.
Members of the Precious Blood who came with Rev. Brunner. |
| 1847-1850 |
Rev. Peter Carabin, Pastor
First signature in records November 25, 1847 |
| 1848-1849 |
Rev. Jacob Ringley |
| September 1850-December 1853 |
Rev. Charles Evrard |
| April 1854-April 1855 |
Rev. Jacob Hamene |
| January 1855-August 1861 |
Rev. J.P. Dolweck |
| September 1861-March 1862 |
Rev. Marie Anton Meyer, C.PP.S. |
| January 1862-June 1866 |
Rev. Andrew Magenheim |
| April-August 1866 |
Rev. F.S. Obermiller |
| June – August 1866 |
Rev. N. Moes, Assistant |
| September – December 1866 |
Rev. E. Haemers, Assistant |
| ? 1866 |
Rev. Damback, Assistant |
| January 1867-May 1868 |
Rev. Frederick C. Ludwig, Pastor |
| May – August 1868 |
No Pastor |
| Summer of 1870 |
Rev. Joseph Fruzzini, S.J., Assistant Rev. Hieber, Assistant
Rev. Huhn, Assistant |
| August 1868-December 1873 |
Rev. Charles Evrard |
| 1884 |
Rev. Bonaventure Faulhaber, S.F., Assistant Assistants here a short time spring 1884 |
| 1874-1888 |
Rev. Michael Dechant |
| January 1888-March 8th 1895 |
Rev. Joseph Blaser |
| March 9th 1895-June 1897 |
Rev. Michael Baker |
| June 1897-December 1899 |
Rev. Leon Lentsch |
| January – May 1900 |
Rev. Rosenberger |
| May 1900-June 1909 |
Rev. Thomas Maria Kolb |
| June 1909-December 1911 |
Rev. John Bertemes |
| June 1912-August 1915 |
Rev. A.G. Herman |
| September 1915-Spring 1917 |
Rev. Nicholaus Espen |
| Spring 1917-December 1921 |
Rev. Albert J. Aust |
| January 1922-March 19th1930 |
Rev. Alexander W. Hasenberg |
| March 1930-March 1935 |
Rev. J.B. Fralick |
| April 1935-June 1953 |
Rev. Marcellus R. Lambillotte |
| June 1953-June 1970 |
Rev. Leo P. Williams, Pastor |
| 1970-1972 |
Rev. Thomas E. Reynolds, Pastor Sister parish of St. Mary's Norwalk |
| 1970-May 1971 |
Rev. Herman Scherger, Assistant |
| May 1971-May 1972 |
Rev. Thomas Ankenbrandt, Assistant |
| 1972-1977 |
Rev. Bertrand Shenk, Pastor |
| 1977-1983 |
Rev. J. Norbert Howe |
| 1983-1987 |
Rev. Raymond Fisher |
| 1987-1988 |
Rev. Herbert Willman |
| 1988-1994 |
Rev. Michael Schelling |
| 1994-2004 |
Rev. Nelson Beaver |
| 2004-present |
Rev. Ken Lill |
